The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.
A fresh legal controversy is unfolding, concerning a disputed hire car bill totaling $29,000, which has now been directed back to court for further review.
This legal clash originated from a vehicular accident in Wollongong, December 2021, where Cameron Lazicic’s car collided with and irreparably damaged Thomas Rossi’s Honda Civic.
While Mr. Lazicic’s insurer, NRMA Insurance, admitted liability for the damages, they refuted the $29,684 bill from credit hire company Right2Drive. This charge was for a Hyundai i30 rented at $343 per day for 86 days, until Mr. Rossi’s car was replaced.
The total bill for the car hire exceeded the cost of purchasing some models of the Hyundai i30 outright. This discrepancy has sparked significant legal debate.
Given NRMA Insurance’s rejection of the credit hire claims, Mr. Rossi proceeded to sue Mr. Lazicic. However, in an interesting turn during the Local Court proceedings, the magistrate observed Mr. Rossi’s apparent confusion and reluctance, noting that credit hire company Right2Drive had likely initiated the lawsuit by exercising a right of subrogation.
Known for offering replacement vehicles to car crash victims with the assurance of reclaiming the expenses from the at-fault party’s insurer, credit hire companies have drawn the ire of motor insurers. The main concerns stem from their substantial fees, which insurers argue inflate claims and, consequently, hike insurance premiums.
NRMA Insurance provided evidence illustrating that alternative hire car services in Wollongong offered rates as low as $90 per day at the time of the accident. Mr. Lazicic maintained that a rental fee of $7380, equivalent to $85.52 per day, was more reasonable. However, the Local Court ruled against him, holding him liable for the full credit hire bill.
In his appeal last month, the NSW Supreme Court’s Justice Jeremy Kirk highlighted a critical lack of communication between Right2Drive and Mr. Rossi about the financial implications of the hire.
Justice Kirk remarked that Mr. Rossi received a call from Right2Drive shortly after the accident. According to the Local Court magistrate, during this call, there was no discussion regarding payment, rates, or potential discounts. Justice Kirk noted, "When asked about agreeing to pay roughly $345 for a fairly ordinary $22,000 car, Mr. Rossi implied he was unaware of the rate being charged." Further, Mr. Rossi did not inquire about the costs involved.
Ultimately, Justice Kirk overturned the Local Court’s initial decision, citing the magistrate’s failure to provide detailed reasoning or critically assess whether Mr. Rossi's actions in incurring the rental expenses were justified.
This matter has been sent back to the Local Court for a new hearing, promising further developments in the ongoing legal battle.
The original source of this story can be found on [Insurance News](https://www.insurancenews.com.au).
Published:Friday, 9th Aug 2024 Source: Paige Estritori
Please Note: If this information affects you, seek advice from a licensed professional.
The Australian Amusement Leisure & Recreation Association (AALARA) has raised concerns over the escalating costs of public liability insurance, which are placing significant pressure on amusement and recreation operators across the country. This warning follows the Insurance Council of Australia's (ICA) recent call for reforms to civil liability laws. - read more
A recent report by the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI) has revealed that small businesses in Australia are paying up to 30% more for their insurance premiums due to taxes and levies imposed by state and territory governments. This financial burden is leading to a worrying trend where an increasing number of small businesses are either underinsuring or forgoing insurance altogether. - read more
The Australian hospitality industry has long been a cornerstone of the nation's economy, offering diverse experiences to both locals and tourists. However, recent challenges, including labour shortages and the need for skilled workers, have prompted the government to take proactive measures. In response, the Australian government, in partnership with Accommodation Australia, has unveiled 'eeger', a comprehensive platform designed to attract, train, and retain talent within the tourism, hospitality, and travel sectors. - read more
In the face of rising operational costs and labour shortages, the Australian hospitality industry is increasingly turning to technology to drive growth and enhance customer experiences. A recent report by Lightspeed highlights that nearly half (47%) of venue operators acknowledge the pivotal role of digital tools in improving operational efficiency. Additionally, 41% noted enhancements in customer service, attributing these improvements to the integration of technology that allows staff to focus more on service delivery. - read more
The Australian hospitality industry is currently grappling with escalating operational costs, posing significant challenges to profitability and sustainability. Factors such as increased supply expenses, labour shortages, and economic uncertainties have converged, creating a complex landscape for businesses in the sector. - read more
Insurance plays a crucial role in safeguarding our financial future. It serves as a safety net, ensuring that we can manage unexpected events without severely impacting our financial stability. For Australian adults, having the right types of insurance coverage is essential for peace of mind and financial security. - read more
Insurance is a crucial component of financial planning. While many Australians understand the importance of life insurance, there's another vital type of coverage that often gets overlooked: income protection insurance. - read more
When the unexpected strikes, such as an illness or injury hindering our ability to earn a living, the financial repercussions can be devastating. This is where income protection insurance becomes a pivotal part of our financial safety net, ensuring a stream of income during challenging times. - read more
Income protection insurance is an essential component of financial security for Australians, designed to provide a safety net by replacing a portion of your income if you're unable to work due to illness or injury. Despite its critical role in safeguarding livelihoods, it's often overlooked in personal financial planning. - read more
Financial security is pivotal for anyone striving to meet their life goals, be it owning a home, educating children, or ensuring a comfortable retirement. In Australia, where uncertainties can disrupt our best laid-out financial plans, having a safety net in place is essential. Income insurance offers just that—protection against the unforeseen events that could impact your income earning abilities. - read more
Start Here !
Apply now for your free Insurance assessment and price comparisons!
